When choosing the best anal toys, comfort, safety, and pleasure should be your top priorities. Look for toys made of body-safe, non-porous materials like silicone, which are easy to clean and hypoallergenic. Consider size and shape—start with smaller toys if you're new, and ensure any toy has a flared base or handle for safety. Lubrication is also crucial for comfort and smoothness, so choose a high-quality, compatible lube.